Question

What specific logical fallacy is committed when someone argues that a policy should be rejected simply because it is similar to a policy enacted by a disliked historical figure?

Accepted Answer

The specific logical fallacy committed when someone argues that a policy should be rejected simply because it is similar to a policy enacted by a disliked historical figure is the &#x27;association fallacy&#x27; or &#x27;guilt by association&#x27;. This fallacy occurs when someone discredits an argument or policy based solely on its association with a person, group, or idea that is viewed negatively. The argument wrongly assumes that because the policy is linked to a disliked figure, the policy itself must be flawed or undesirable, without actually examining the policy&#x27;s merits or drawbacks independently. The focus shifts from the substance of the policy to the irrelevant characteristic of its association, thereby avoiding a rational evaluation of the policy&#x27;s potential consequences.

Home → All Courses → Social Science Courses → Critical Thinking and Information Literacy Certificate → Flashcard

What specific logical fallacy is committed when someone argues that a policy should be rejected simply because it is similar to a policy enacted by a disliked historical figure?

The specific logical fallacy committed when someone argues that a policy should be rejected simply because it is similar to a policy enacted by a disliked historical figure is the 'association fallacy' or 'guilt by association'. Thi....