Question

What is the primary difference between a deficit-based approach and a positive deviance approach when identifying solutions within a community?

Accepted Answer

A deficit-based approach focuses on identifying and fixing what is broken within a community, operating under the assumption that external experts must intervene to resolve problems by providing resources or solutions that are currently missing. This method treats the community as a collection of needs or gaps, often relying on top-down strategies where outsiders determine the remedy for the identified shortcomings. In contrast, a positive deviance approach relies on the premise that some individuals or groups in a community already possess unique, successful solutions to their problems despite having access to the same limited resources as everyone else. This strategy involves identifying these &#x27;positive deviants&#x27;—those who achieve better outcomes than their peers—and helping the rest of the community adopt those locally developed, culturally appropriate practices. Think of a deficit-based approach like a doctor diagnosing a patient’s illness to prescribe medicine from a pharmacy, while a positive deviance approach is like finding the one person in an impoverished village who successfully raises healthy children and asking them to teach their neighbors their specific cooking or hygiene secrets.

Home → All Courses → Social Science Courses → Positive Deviance → Flashcard

What is the primary difference between a deficit-based approach and a positive deviance approach when identifying solutions within a community?

Community Answers