Govur University Logo
--> --> --> -->
...

Describe the limitations of using only Dissolved Gas Analysis (DGA) to determine the exact location of a fault within a power transformer.



While Dissolved Gas Analysis (DGA) is a valuable tool for detecting and diagnosing faults in power transformers, it has limitations in pinpointing the exact location of a fault within the transformer. DGA identifies the presence and concentration of various gases dissolved in the transformer oil, which are produced by the decomposition of oil and paper insulation due to thermal or electrical stress. Different fault types generate different gas profiles, but these profiles are not specific enough to precisely locate the fault. DGA provides a general indication of the type and severity of the fault, but it does not provide spatial information. For example, DGA can indicate overheating, but it cannot tell whether the overheating is occurring in the windings, the core, or the tap changer. The gas concentrations measured in DGA are an average of the gas production throughout the transformer. The gases diffuse and mix within the oil, making it difficult to trace the gases back to their source. Similar gas patterns can be generated by faults in different locations. For example, overheating can be caused by hot spots in the windings due to poor cooling or by core lamination shorts. DGA cannot differentiate between these two scenarios. The presence of multiple faults can further complicate the interpretation of DGA results and make it even more difficult to locate the source of the gas generation. To overcome these limitations, other diagnostic tests are used in conjunction with DGA to pinpoint the location of the fault. Electrical tests, such as insulation resistance tests (Megger), turns ratio tests, and frequency response analysis (FRA), provide information about the condition of the windings and core. Oil sampling from different locations within the transformer can help to narrow down the source of the gas generation. For example, taking oil samples near the tap changer can help to determine if the tap changer is the source of the problem. Internal inspection is often necessary to confirm the location and nature of the fault. This involves removing the transformer from service and opening it up for visual inspection and further testing. Therefore, DGA is a valuable tool for detecting faults, but it should be used in conjunction with other diagnostic tests to accurately locate the fault within the transformer.